
I’ve been planning to make peperonata all week, but somehow I just haven’t managed to get around to it. As you can see, tonight I finally managed to make time and all I can say is that the wait was really worthwhile!
This recipe is a real winner for me as it really is all about the peppers. I’ve seen (and tasted) other recipes where the peppers are swimming in either a thick oily tomato sauce or floating on a very thin sauce. In this case, the sauce clings to each strip of pepper and onion and just complements the natural vegetable flavours rather than overwhelming them. Yum!
I paired the peperonata with some fresh garlic and herb pasta and also a herb-grilled chicken breast. The chicken is incredibly easy to prepare mainly because I cheat. Bart Spices make a wonderful blend/paste of fresh mediterranean herbs in sunflower oil which makes a fantastic rub for chicken and pork prior to grilling. Of course, you could make your own rub and feel extremely virtuous! (If I remember correctly, the blend contains basil, rosemary, sage, oregano and savoury.)
Peperonata is a slightly extravagent dish unless you have a source of good (i.e. tasty!) bell peppers which are reasonably priced. Most of the peppers sold in UK supermarkets are expensive, mass-produced and pretty tasteless to boot. However, you do occasionally get good organic ones which are perfect for showcasing in this dish….
Peperonata, from “A New Way To Cook” by Sally Schneider
Serves 4
WW points (UK): 1
1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon extra-virgin olive oil
1 large onion sliced into half-moons approx 1/4″ thick
4 cloves garlic sliced thinly
1/4 tsp sea salt
4 red or yellow peppers (or a mixture of both) seeded and sliced into 1/4″ strips
3-4 tablespoons water
1 tablespoon tomato puree
4 tablespoons finely chopped basil or parsley
2 tbsp sliced olives or pine nuts
pepper
Heat a medium frying pan over moderate heat. Add the oil and continue to heat until oil is hot but not smoking.
Add the onion and garlic and saute for approximately five minutes until the onion is beginning to turn brown. You need to keep the mixture moving in the pan otherwise the garlic will burn and turn bitter. Add the pepper strips and saute for a further one minute, stirring frequently.
Cover the pan and turn the heat down to low. Cook for five minutes until the peppers have started to soften and have released some juice.
Remove the lid and continue to cook for 20 minutes until the peppers are very soft. Stir frequently.
Add the water and tomato puree to the pan. Mix well and cook for a further 10 minutes until almost all of the liquid has boiled away. You should be left with velvety tender strips of vegetables with an almost creamy tomato sauce clinging to them.
Stir in the basil, olives and a good grinding of black pepper.
Serve hot or warm.
Will keep for a week in the fridge.
Follow me on Twitter
Become a Facebook fan


This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Great description of what a good peperonata should be. Couldn’t agree more. I never added olives and pinenuts to peperonata but since they work great in other pepper dishes I’ll definitely give it a try next time. Thanks for the tip.
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Dear Angela,
A great recipe, thank you. May I add some of the thing I tried ( although it makes my result less traditional and more fusion).
First I peel the peppers, either by running them under the grill first or by using a very good peeler like the one I bought at Betty Bossi in Switzerland. This makes the dish more digestible, at the risk of losing some taste.
After sautéing the peppers, I use a tablespoon or so of Noilly Prat or Dry Martini to loosen up, before adding the tomatoes, which I sometimes do in the form of tomato juice. As you say, it is key to keep the sauce very very restricted, as required with braised Mediterranean dishes. May I also suggest substituting dry wine, eg. Sauvignon, to water, in which case the taste greatly improves if you leave the dish overnight in the fridge. Instead of basil, thyme and/or rosemary can be added, after sautéing, in the form of very finely chopped leaves.
Take care, Sergio.
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Hi Sergio – Thank-you for such a wonderful comment & I’m glad you enjoyed the recipe. I did consider peeling the peppers but I find it quite fiddly to do so and the skins aren’t too intrusive in this dish. (Plus, my mum always reminds me that all the goodness is just under the skin!) I think the fairly long cooking time helps to refine the skins. I love the idea of adding Martini to deglaze the pan and white wine instead of water. I can imagine that would lead to a very refined taste. I’ll have to try that next time.
For a truely Mediterranean fusion meal – the next day we finished off the peperonata with some more grilled chicken breast (plain this time), all stuffed into garlic pita breads and topped off with some good houmous. Astonishingly good!