
On Thursday I finally admitted to myself that the huge batch of mincemeat I made last year simply wasn’t up to scratch. I’d been seduced by the marvellous prose surrounding Tamasin Day-Lewis’ family recipe in “Good Tempered Food” but it turned out to be utterly lacking in succulence when cooked (odd considering how much suet it called for). Very disappointing, especially since I had such vivid memories of the moist, boozy, luscious goodness of Nigella’s suet-free apple mincemeat which I made in 2001.
And so, it was with considerable relief that I set to work chopping apples all the apples needed for “Hettie Potter’s Mincemeat” and beaming with pleasure as my kitchen filled with all the smells of Christmas. The best thing about this mincemeat is that you can use it immediately and still have wonderful mince-pies. If you let it mature for a month then you will have amazing mince-pies; and if you let it mature for a year, you will have sublime mince-pies. I know people say that you shouldn’t keep mince-meat for so long, but everything is cooked and the hefty finishing touch of rum keeps everything safe. I suspect a little fermentation does still take place, but I certainly don’t object to even boozier mince-pies!
Nigella’s Frangipane Mince Pie recipe really showcases this mincemeat. Dense, buttery, almondy pies with an incredible burst of complex mincemeat in the middle. I’ve often used the frangipane topping with a plain shortcrust pastry (which works extremely well), but this year I decided to make the sweet almond pastry and complete the Nigella Experience.
The pastry is very forgiving; I’m not particularly good at rolling pastry out (it always sticks, no matter how much flour I use on board or pin) and thus spend a lot of time patching the pastry and generally over-working it shamefully. The mince-pies made with the re-rolled pastry scraps taste just as good as their virgin sisters. Plus, all the re-rolling meant that I managed to get an extra five mince-pies out of the recipe!
We’ve been munching these mince-pies on their own, heated up with double cream poured over, and I’m thinking of whipping some cream along with a little bit of mandarin liqueur and dolloping that on top….
Frangipane Mince Pies, from How To Be A Domestic Goddess (Nigella Lawson)
for the pastry:
175g plain flour, preferably Italian 00
30g ground almonds
65g icing sugar
pinch of salt
125g cold unsalted butter, diced
2 large egg yolks, beaten with a tablespoon of iced water
for the topping:
approximately 200g mincemeat
2 large eggs
90g caster sugar
90g unsalted butter, melted
90g ground almonds
4 tablespoons flaked almonds
2 x 12-bun tartlet trays
7cm fluted biscuit cutter
Make the pastry by putting the flour, ground almonds, sugar and salt into the bowl of the food processor and pulse to combine. Add the diced butter and process till you�ve got a flaky, crumbly mix. Now start adding, tablespoon by tablespoon, the egg and water mix down the funnel, pulsing as you do so, until the pastry looks like it�s about to form a ball around the blade. Turn it out onto a surface, press to form a cohesive dough, shape into 2 discs, cover with clingfilm and put into the fridge to rest for 30 minutes. Roll out one of the discs and stamp out 12 circles slightly larger than the tart indentations. Press these in gently, patting base and sides and put back in the fridge for 15 minutes. Preheat the oven to 200�C/Gas Mark 6.
Put a scant teaspoon of mincemeat into each pastry-lined cavity. In a bowl, beat together the eggs and sugar, then pour in, still beating, the melted butter. Stir in the ground almonds and then dollop a tablespoon of this mixture on top. Sprinkle with flaked almonds and then put in the oven to cook for 15 minutes, or until the pastry is cooked through and the frangipane gold and brown-flecked.
Take out of the oven and leave to cool in the tins for 5 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool. When the tin�s cold, repeat with the second disc, remaining mincemeat and frangipane.
Makes 24.
Follow me on Twitter
Become a Facebook fan


This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Soooo….. what’s Hettie Potter’s mincemeat? I googled it and came up empty!
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
I felt bad about giving two recipes in one post! Hettie Potter’s Suet-Free Mincemeat is definitely worth the price of the book though!
Its basically cooking apples, raisins, currants and spices simmered in hard cider and dark brown sugar. With a big glug of brandy or dark rum to finish it off. It’s very, very moist and yummy!
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Ah, of course — both Nigella’s recipes. Silly me. I’ve been meaning to buy this book for some time, this is just another reason to ask for it for Christmas!
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Please please can you tell me how long mince pies will keep once they have been made? I have done some for a christmas hamper for the in-laws, wrapped in two layers of greaseproof paper and then two layers of celophane so it’s airtight (i hope!). I made them on the 14th of December and I just want to know if they will be ok up to the 27th? I have searched and searched the internet but can’t find a satisfactory answer.
can you help?!
Francesca Ireland
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
Oh my god those look good. I wish the web had smell-o-vision.
This long-lost comment has been restored from backup.
I accidentally opened your Christmas present a day early! It can happen… honest!
Looks absolutely GORGEOUS.
Can’t wait for tomorrow and a legitimate excuse to try that cake !
With regard to how long mince pies will keep for… I really don’t know!
I can, however, tell you that I made a batch on Sunday, which are still absolutely fine today (Thursday), but as numbers are dwindling in the tin, I honestly couldn’t say how well they’d keep beyond a week.
Really want to try these.. but do they freeze well? I usually make Delia’s mince pies but with almond pastry..and she recommends making them up to the “about to go in oven stage” and then freezing them in the tart tin. When they’re frozen solid, you simply tip them into a container and store. Then when you need them fill up the tray again with the frozen pies and bake accordingly. Can I apply this method with Frangipane??
I also must share with you my secret ingredient to make shop bought mincemeat utterly delicious. Go and buy a bottle of Pedro Ximenez Sherry (or PX Sherry). It’s a dessert sherry from Spain made with raisins so complements perfectly and is Xmas in a glass. Mix and glug or two and some toasted flaked almonds into the jar of mincemeat… you can then serve a small glass with the hot mincepies or stir a glug of PX marbelled into a bowl of extra thick double cream (whipped) to go along side.
Hi Stella! I’ve never frozen these mince pies, either baked or unbaked. However, frangipane does freeze well, so it’s worth a go.
Thanks for your mincemeat tips. Adding PX is a fantastic idea!!