As much as I love cheesecake—and that’s a lot—I hate that it typically is loaded with saturated fat and an excess of calories. So, whenever it is possible, I start trying to pare it back to something approaching healthiness. Mainly, it has to be said, so that I can eat more of it, Did I mention that I’m greedy?
The latest cheesecake to go under the knife, so to speak, is Nigella Lawson’s Gleaming Maple Cheesecake from Nigella Christmas.
I had planned to bake this cheesecake as a dessert for New Year’s Day, but the flu put paid to that. So, once I was better and feeling more enthusiastic about spending time in my kitchen again, I set to work adapting the original recipe…
To lighten things up, I’ve used extra-low fat cream cheese and substituted egg whites for most of the whole eggs called for. I did keep one whole egg to ensure that the cheesecake set properly and to help keep the texture silky smooth. The crust is, admittedly, a bit of a departure from Nigella’s recipe: I’ve used my standard cheesecake crust which is a mixture of Grape Nut cereal and amaretti biscuits. It still has a slightly nutty taste and the flavour works perfectly with the rest of the cheesecake. And really… who cares that much about the crust? We’re here for the cheesecake. All my fiddling brought the cheesecake down from 13 Weight Watchers (UK) points per slice down to just 4. Quite a difference, eh?
But… does it taste good?
Yes!! I’m really pleased with this cheesecake. You absolutely can’t tell that it’s a low-fat version and baking in the water-bath as stipulated by Nigella has kept it amazingly creamy all the way through. The smoky-sweet maple flavour shines through and balances the creaminess of the cheese, yet isn’t sickly sweet.
Treat yourself to an extra drizzle of maple syrup on each slice… it tips it over into absolute luxury without breaking the calorie bank!
Lightened Gleaming Maple Cheesecake
Adapted from Nigella Christmas by Nigella Lawson
Serves 8
WW (UK) points: 4 per slice
- 75g Grape Nut cereal
- 75g amaretti biscuits
- 2 large egg whites
- 500g Philadelphia extra-light at room temperature
- 1 1/2 tablespoons plain flour
- 40g caster sugar
- 100ml best-quality maple syrup
- 3 large egg whites
- 1 large egg
- 1/2 teaspoon lemon juice
You will need a 7″ springform tin, tinfoil and a deep baking dish that will comfortably hold the tin.
Preheat the oven to 180C (fan 160).
Put the dry ingredients in a blender or food processor and process to coarse crumbs. Tip into a bowl.
Lightly beat the egg whites until frothy, and mix with the crumbs until thoroughly combined.
Lightly spray the springform tin with oil spray. Scrape the crumb mixture into the tin and, with the back of a serving spoon, spread it evenly over the bottom and up the sides. Take the crust all the way up to the top of the tin – the cheesecake mixture comes almost to the brim. If the crust sticks to the spoon then dip the spoon in some cold water.
Bake in the oven for 7-10 minutes, then leave to cool (in the tin!) on a wire rack.
Boil a kettle of water.
Beat the cream cheese until light and fluffy (I used my KitchenAid, but a handmixer works very well, and I’m sure elbow grease would, too.) Remember, everything for the filling must be at room temperature!!
Add the flour and beat in, scraping down the sides to incorporate everything. Slowly beat in the sugar and maple syrup then the eggs, one at a time. Lastly, beat in the lemon juice.
Wrap the sprinfrom tin in two layers of tinfoil and set in a deep baking dish large enough to take the tin. Pour the cheesecake mixture into the crust then pour the hot water from the kettle around the foil-wrapped tin.
Bake for around one hour, until the edge of the cheesecake is set and the centre jiggles ever so slightly when you shake the dish.
Remove from the oven, take out of the water-bath and carefully strip away the tinfoil. Cool cheesecake in tin on a wire rack before chilling for at least 5 hours. Overnight is best if you have the time.
Serve slices with extra maple syrup poured over the top.

Follow me on Twitter
Become a Facebook fan


Hi Angela, this looks really awesome! Haven’t had cheesecake for aaages – must rectify this!
Do you have any hints for avoiding cracks on the top as the cheesecake sets/cools? Or indeed when making any kind of cooked custard type dessert – I find lemon tart a particular offender…
This looks divine! I like that its sort of low fat too, makes me feel less terrible for eating it! I have never actually made cheesecake before but I think this will be one for me to try out.
Hi Emma! Thank-you
I usually run a knife round the edge of the cheesecake while it is cooling so that it doesn’t tear away from the edge and crack. I very rarely get cracks in my cheesecakes and I’m pretty sure it’s because of that. Obviously that wouldn’t work for the lemon tart—not sure what to suggest there.
Hi Katy! As cheesecakes go, this is pretty low fat and full of useful trace elements from the maple syrup. It’s really easy to make, so do let me know how it goes!
I Wwas going to make this over Crimbo, but like you was struck down by a horrible virus. Will have to make n effort to make this one before next Christmas
Glad to see that making it low fat work Angela!
Thanks for the hint, will try that!
This looks delicious, I love anything maple! It’s great that you came up with a way to lighten up cheesecake.
I`m going to try that one now. I got the book in the sales after Christmas. I love Nigella, but I sometimes find that her recipes don`t work. Good to know this one does. It looks lovely
Yum! I love cheesecake. Great idea using amaretti biscuits for the base.
It looks a stunner – great photo too!
Sounds delicious. I’m glad your low fat version worked. I too love cheesecake but try not to eat it too often, but this one sounds great.
this looks delish!
Maple Cheesecake… It has my mouth humming. And a lightened version? All the better – I can eat more (But that’s the point, isn’t it?)
I can definitely vouch how wonderful this cheesecake is having made it over Christmas for a dinner party with the in laws, it was a great success and everyone loved it. Yours turned out absolutely delish!
Maria
x
i never knew cheesecake ingredients could be that simple. i will try making one for Chinese New Year.
I am not really into cheesecake, but I think this one sounds really good. I love that it doesn’t use the typical crust, and the addition of maple, yum!
Oh wow! That sounds terrific. INtrigued by the idea of baking it in a water bath, and how can anybody resist maple syrup?
That maple cheesecake looks so good!
Hi Angela,
Your cheesecake looks delicious. I love that it’s lowfat too. Great crumb mixture ingredients. I would love to give this a try. Looks so delicious!
You’ve done a great job paring this one down to 4 points!
We always use low fat cream cheese in desserts these days and nobody can tell the difference. Maybe it’s because so many people use the low fat version for other purposes and are used to the texture and taste